Best Italian Restaurant in Indian River

The main dining room was erected in 1938 and at that time the business was run by Fred Bradley. It was the Gypsy Tavern and advertised in the local paper as the House of Sandwiches. Fred Bradley died in 1939, and Minnie ran the business until it was acquired by Docker. Then Quick's bought it from Docker's, and Vivio's purchased it from Quick's. John and Theresa Vivio started the Italian cuisine and upon their sale of the restaurant to Middleton's in 1973, it has remained the same cuisine and atmosphere henceforth. Kurt and Angie Oswald purchased the restaurant from the Middleton's in 2000, continuing the beloved tradition of Italian cuisine in the same charming building. In 2023 we purchased the building and we are still in the same location and proud of it, serving up the same great pizza recipe!